Welcome to Carlo's Pizza Oven
At Carlo's Pizza Oven, nestled in the heart of Riverhead, NY, our story is crafted from passion and tradition. We pride ourselves on serving a diverse array of pizzas, from classic cheese to unique creations like the Chicken Bacon Ranch. Each dish is made fresh daily, ensuring quality in every bite. Our warm and inviting atmosphere feels like home, where friendly faces greet you like family. Whether savoring our delectable cheese calzones or indulging in a shrimp parmigiana, patrons feel the love and dedication in every meal. Join us, and experience the heartfelt flavors that make Carlo’s a beloved local gem.
Carlo's Pizza Oven: Reviews & Ratings
LOVE the chicken fingers! The food is great! Now the service is AWESOME!! Like the people there are so nice! They’re like, “Hello! What can I get you” or something like that. And the atmosphere. Looks great! The decoration here is nice! Could work on some holiday stuff like maybe a Christmas tree! In conclusion, AWESOME!!!
Delicious and crunchy slides of pizza. Neighborhood was a bit creepy for night
This was my first visit and it felt like I had been going there my while life. The guy behind the counter seemed to know everyone coming in and The entire process was amazing. Never felt so at home. Can't wait to be back in the area so I can order again.
Knowing how subjective pizza is because it tends to be based from what a person's expectation are, I will be willing to say this pizza is very good. I tried a chicken slice and was very happy with it's freshness and the crust they use. I would come here any day of the week over any chain pizza stores hands down! This is my first visit here and I can say it will not be my last. Back for another visit, today's slice is the CBR, Chicken Bacon Ranch slice. It was very tasty with a nice smokiness to the bacon and just enough ranch dressing without going overboard. It was a very delicious well-balanced slice. This slice is not to be avoided!
Great local spot that recently changed hands after 40 years owned by another local in the neighborhood. Riverhead is underrated and soon the neighborhood by the train station will be restored and meanwhile enjoy the 2 pizza and drink special during the week.
Good place especially Pete he’s the nicest man there I like it just the Hispanic guy a little off but other than that everything is good local but no issues
The salad is delicious and the pizza is so soft and cheesy.
Ordered a sausage calzone and it was fresh and hot. Some of the best quality cheese (mozzarella and ricotta) I've ever had in a calzone. Person who took my order was kind and attentive and even brought the calzone to my table. Would come back again!
Location
-
435 Osborn Ave, Riverhead, NY 11901, United States Hotline: +1 631-369-2010
Welcome to Carlo's Pizza Oven, a hidden gem located at 435 Osborn Ave in Riverhead, NY. This vibrant eatery serves as a comforting hub for pizza lovers, offering a delightful array of mouthwatering pizzas and classic appetizers that promise to satisfy every craving.
At Carlo's, the menu features a variety of delectable pizzas that cater to diverse palates. Some of the standout options include:
- Sausage Pizza - A robust option that appeals to meat lovers.
- Eggplant Pizza - A vegetarian delight that highlights freshness.
- Fresh Peppers Pizza - Bursting with flavor and color.
- Salami Pizza - A zesty choice that complements the base perfectly.
- Black Olives Pizza - Adding a briny richness to the mix.
- Ricotta Cheese Pizza - Creamy and indulgent in every bite.
- Meatballs Pizza - A hearty slice that’ll leave you wanting more.
- Extra Cheese Pizza - For those who can’t get enough cheese!
The appetizer selection is equally impressive, featuring Carlo's Famous Garlic Rolls—light and fluffy with a perfect garlic sauce, and mozzarella sticks that come with a tangy marinara. The chicken fingers are breaded and fried to golden perfection, offering a delightful crunch that complements any meal. Don’t miss their Pasta Fagioli Soup, a warm and heartening choice that hits the spot on chilly days.
But it's not just the food that sets Carlo's apart; the atmosphere is warmly inviting. Many customers echo similar sentiments, highlighting the friendly service and the feeling of being at home. As one patron noted, “It felt like I had been going there my whole life.” This sense of community is palpable, further enhanced by the cheerful demeanor of the staff who treat you like family.
In the words of a satisfied customer, “The food is great! Now the service is AWESOME!!” Whether it’s your first visit or a regular stop, you can expect a welcoming experience that makes every meal feel special.
So, if you find yourself in Riverhead, Carlo's Pizza Oven is a must-visit. With delicious offerings and a homey vibe, it’s not just a meal; it’s an experience. Come indulge in their tasty slices and let the warmth of Carlo’s make your day just a little brighter!